International rulings on deeming fiction under domestic law and its inter-play with domestic tax treaty and home permanent establishment
CA Hiren Shah
CA Liona Gracias
Part A – International ruling on deeming fiction under domestic law and its inter-play with domestic tax treaty – The case of United Kingdom – Fowler v. HMRC – HRMC [2020] 116 taxmann.com 713 (SC-UK)
“the influence of the fiction extends to every department of the jurist’s activities” Lon Fuller
BACKGROUND AND ISSUE INVOLVED
Interplay between tax treaties and domestic law is a complex one. A recent ruling of the U.K. Supreme Court, elucidates the following important aspects on this matter, viz.:
- the extent to which a deeming fiction in domestic tax law can be referred to interpret the terms of a tax treaty or to apply an article of a tax treaty;
the point of time at which such reference is required to be made;
.......